It's OP because it's better than every other title in the game, and much easier to get.
Just because everyone gets a fair chance of having it doesn't mean it's not OP.
Everything people said on the Nui's Chosen event title before it was nerfed still applies (comments like this one for example)...
I thought you guys had learned your lesson with the Champion of Auroria title, but nope, here we are with another super OP title, except this time with a disclaimer that you'll never balance it. 'idk
The fact that Archery is weak is no secret to most AA players, you need to put a lot more effort both in skill and gear to match other classes' power. But Sjin already replied here with the Staff's stance on trying to balance classes. I'm not happy with the response, but no point in arguing it...