Higher Success Rates vs Lower Success Rates with no Gem Loss
Gems are a pretty big deal and the players that put in the work to get all the honor (and got lucky) to have all their stuff socketed might not like the idea of socketing being made easier (elitist mindset and all that). However if it was made to be a bit more difficult to get everything to socket, RNG wise, but didn't punish you for the shit rates, the people that got all their stuff socketed could be more inclined to like or tolerate the change. Everyone that plays this game is no stranger to the terrible rates and I think that not losing your previous gems, while maintaining the harsh socket rates, would be a way to please both sides of the issue.
If socket rates were higher, there is still a chance for failure. This failure would still lead to all previous gems in that item to be destroyed.. Even if the chance to socket 5 gems goes something like: 100, 95, 90, 85, 80; there is still a chance for failure is still there. I personally think that failure to socket should not screw over your previous successfully socketed gems. Even if you fail socketing the 5th gem 100 times, I think it is more appealing to have kept my 4 other gems than have a higher chance of success but losing my progress every time I fail.
Another thing to note is how a large portion of events are PVP events and while you don't have to have gems to participate, it is highly encouraged you do. Nothing sucks more than trying to socket more gems, failing, and ending up weaker as a result. With the previous gems staying, it would prevent players from possibly crippling themselves when failing to socket.
Which situation sounds more appealing to you:
- Failing your 5th gem and proceeding to spend 100k honor to end up with 1 or 2 gems even though you statistically had a higher chance of success.
- Failing your 5th gem and proceeding to spend 100k honor only to end up not earning any more sockets; however, the 4 gems prior to your 5th attempt remain in the gear.
Increased rates do not guarantee an easier time socketing. I believe the biggest thing is to not be put at a disadvantage for failing rather than the hope that the increased rates will give you (statistically) an easier time.
(I've reformated this post like 3 times now, sorry for anyone who may have read it before and is now confused. I think this gets my point across a little better.)